The Optimal Use of Natural Resources in light of Intergenerational Eq-uity

Abstract:

Sustainable development entails the preservation of capital for future generations – most particularly: the natural capital. Market mechanism is neither sufficient nor adequate for the purpose of ensuring intergenerational maximization of income and wealth. Consequently, it places future generations in a precarious position of being devoid of their effective potential to control and manage the environmental resources. This paper provides an overview of those economic models of resource management which bear associations with the realization of the principle of intergenerational equity as the key element in effective implementation of the sustainable development postulates. The paper represents an attempt at identifying those of the presently adopted economic models of resource management which are best suited to reinforce the realization of the idea of intergenerational equity and the durable qualities of sustainable development. The following methods were employed in the study: identification, critical analysis, comparative analysis, and expert evaluation of economic models. Based on definitions of fundamental concepts established in the initial section of the paper, the author identified those of the presently adopted models which ensure the realization of the postulate of intergenerational equity. Three main models were identified: the utilitarian criterion, the Rawls criterion, and the Chichilnisky criterion. These were analysed and evaluated for their utility, validity, and conformity with the principle of intergenerational equity. The findings of the study are in favour of the Chichilnisky criterion as best suited for the realization of the idea of equity, both inter- and intra-generational, as it takes into account the interests of both the present and the future generations. This criterion was also found to best represent the durability aspects of sustainable development. These observations aside, it must also be noted that scientific research of equity in generational access to resources faces a number of limitations and obstacles, including: the largely indeterminate point of generational transition, the unknown structure of preferences displayed by future consumers, and the lack of potential for effective prediction of technological progress.